Military Justice in Ukraine: Human Rights Defenders Explain Risks of Restoring Military Courts
An analysis by the «Pryncyp» human rights center demonstrates why bringing back military courts and prosecutor offices will not solve systemic issues for service members and may create risks for their rights.
🎓EducationPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- The Pryncyp center analyzed initiatives regarding military justice
- Establishing military courts creates risks of command vertical influence
- The introduction of civil judge specialization is proposed instead of new courts
Discussions regarding the reform of the military justice system in Ukraine are ongoing against the backdrop of the Verkhovna Rada's Temporary Special Commission. The issue has become particularly urgent following the full-scale invasion, as proponents of restoring military courts insist that cases involving service members should be judged exclusively by individuals with military experience. However, the «Pryncyp» human rights center for service members has analyzed these proposals and concluded that they pose serious risks to the independence of the judiciary.
The Conflict Between Command Authority and Judicial Independence
The main issue with establishing military courts lies in a fundamental contradiction. Legal proceedings in Ukraine are based on the principles of impartiality and independence, whereas military service is built on strict subordination and single-command authority. If judges are granted military ranks, the question of potential influence from the Ministry of Defense or the General Staff over this process inevitably arises. Furthermore, a judge in uniform would be subject to general disciplinary statutes, creating a direct threat of interference in decision-making.
Recent years have shown attempts to increase liability for military personnel. Specifically, legislative initiatives in 2022 and 2025 aimed to toughen penalties for subordinates regarding unauthorized unit leaves or disobedience, while equivalent strict regulations targeting command abuses were not introduced. Within a separate military court vertical, such pressure on decision-making could easily become systemic.
Instead of rebuilding a cumbersome and potentially dependent military court structure, human rights advocates propose introducing narrow specialization for existing civil judges. Over years of full-scale war, the current judicial system has already accumulated significant practice in handling service-related cases. Whenever special expertise is required, the law allows for engaging specialized professionals or ordering appropriate expert assessments.
For residents of Podilsk and the local community, which includes numerous families of service members, the issue of protecting defenders' rights in court is extremely sensitive. Effective and impartial case review free from administrative command pressure guarantees fairness and adherence to the rule of law for both enlisted personnel and officers, ensuring genuine protection of their interests within the legal framework.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
🧠AI AnalysisBelgian airspace to face total shutdown amid air traffic controllers' strike
On November 23, Belgium will suspend all flights due to a nationwide protest against austerity measures involving air traffic controllers.
🛡️SecurityRussian vessel Sparta II, hit by Ukrainian drones, continues to burn in the Gulf of Finland
Rescue operations are ongoing in Finnish territorial waters to extinguish a fire on the Russian cargo ship Sparta II following a Ukrainian drone attack.
🧠AI AnalysisBehind the Scenes of European Tours: How Ukrainian Theaters Navigate Challenges Abroad
The European tours of Ukrainian theatrical performances have evolved into complex logistical operations and vital social bridges for expatriates. Producer Serhii Chudaiev…
🚨EventsElina Svitolina and Marta Kostyuk Nominated for Prestigious WTA Awards Following Season Success
Top Ukrainian tennis players Elina Svitolina and Marta Kostyuk have been shortlisted for the Women's Tennis Association annual awards.
Russian forces strike Zhytomyr region energy infrastructure four times in a day
Over the past 24 hours, Russian forces carried out four drone strikes against energy facilities in the Zhytomyr region, attempting to cut off electricity and heating.
Slovakia Refuses to Participate in New €45 Billion EU Loan for Ukraine
Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico announced that his country will not take part in the EU's new €45 billion loan to Ukraine, arguing that such support prolongs the confli…